This is a big week for taxes and technology. State "insurance exchanges"
are scheduled to open for business under the Affordable Care Act, which
lets consumers sign up for tax-subsidized individual health insurance.
The White House has already announced that technological glitches will
delay online enrollment on the small business ("SHOP") and
Spanish-language sites. That's a decidedly 21st-century, "first world"
problem. So, why on earth is the IRS lassoing an 1884 law dealing with
lost Civil War horses to regulate tax preparers?
Right now, there are no industry-wide rules governing tax preparers. So,
back in 2011, the IRS announced their new "Return Preparer Initiative,"
which required preparers to register with the IRS, pass a competency
test, and take continuing education classes. The new rules apply to any
tax preparer who isn't already regulated as an attorney, Certified
Public Accountant (CPA), or Enrolled Agent (EA).
In 2012, a group of preparers sued to stop the program, arguing that the
IRS lacked congressional authority to enforce it. Earlier this year,
Judge James Boasberg agreed, shutting down the program. Naturally, the
IRS appealed. And that brings us to our horses.
After the Civil War, thousands of Americans who had lost horses in the
conflict brought war loss claims against the government. A whole stable
full of agents emerged to press claims for the victims, usually for a
piece of the recovery. Would you be shocked to learn that some of those
claims were bogus, with greedy agents representing broken-down old nags
as "Sea Biscuit"-class steeds? So the government passed the "Enabling
Act of 1884" — also referred to as "the Horse Act of 1884" — to grant
the Treasury Department permission to regulate them. (You remember all
of this from high-school history, right? OK, neither did we.)
Well, last week, the IRS took their appeal to court, and saddled their
argument on the Horse Law. Gil Rothenberg, who argued the government's
case, said "I hate to beat a dead horse, especially one from the Civil
War." But he argued that tax preparers represent clients just like
19th-century "enrolled agents" represented theirs. Therefore, he says,
the 1884 law gives the Treasury the same authority to regulate today's
tax preparers.
"Hold your horses," say the tax preparers who filed the case! Today's tax preparers merely provide a service
to their clients. They don't actually "represent" them before the
government the same way attorneys, CPAs, and EAs all do. That makes the
19th-century law a horse of a different color, with no binding authority
to today's case.
Tax experts who observed the oral arguments report the judges sounded
skeptical of the IRS's argument. We should know sometime early next year
what the final decision will be. Of course, if Congress doesn't like
the results, they can simply saddle up new legislation to hobble the
Court.
We think the real question isn't who regulates your tax professionals. We think the real question is what sort of attitude
a tax professional brings to the table. Are they content to put the
right numbers in the right boxes on the right forms, then call it a day?
Or do they give you the plan you need to create the savings you really want? So call us for that plan. And remember, we're here for your whole herd!
Kenneth Hoffman of K.R. Hoffman & Co., LLC is a highly sought after
tax and business counselor. Counseling Entrepreneurs, Professionals and
Select Individuals who are struggling with ever changing tax laws and
who are paying too much in taxes. All the while he is protecting his
clients from the IRS and other taxing authorities using proactive tax
planning strategies, ensuring compliance with minimal tax liability while bringing his clients Peace of Mind.
Discover
how I can help you overcome your tax and business challenges. To start
the conversation or to become a client, call Kenneth Hoffman at (954)
591-8290 Monday - Friday between 8:30 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. for a no cost
consultation, or drop me a note.
If you found this article helpful, I invite you to leave a comment and please share it on twitter, facebook or your favorite social media site and with your friends, family and colleagues. Thank you.
I
truly value your business and I appreciate your referrals. Refer your
family, friends, acquaintances, and business colleagues to KR Hoffman
& Co., LLC.
Follow us on Twitter at @TaxReturnCoach, and let us know how we're doing.