Today's tight economy is forcing governments at every level to
stretch for new revenue, with varying degrees of success. In Washington,
the dysfunctional family known as "Congress" just raised the top income
tax rate to 39.6%, and there are new taxes on earned income and
investment income as well. But when President Obama proposed cutting
loopholes to raise even more money as an alternative to the budget
sequester, his idea was met mostly with scorn.
governments are in fiscal hot water, too. But Illinois may be worst off
of all. Nearly $100 billion in unfunded pension liability is crushing
the state budget. Last week, the bond ratings agency Standard &
Poor's downgraded the Land of Lincoln's score to last in the nation.
Ratings rival Moodys ranks Illinois at the same level as the African
nation of Botswana. (Some observers might ask what else you could expect
from a state that defines "bipartisanship" as having both Democratic and Republican ex-governors in jail at the same time.)
cash crunch has left Illinois's discretionary spending programs gasping
for funding. So it's no surprise that beleaguered lawmakers are looking
for creative ways to protect favored programs. And one representative
thinks he's found a solution. State Rep. Will Davis (D-Hazel Crest) has
proposed a 25 cent tax on athletic shoes which would raise $3 million
per year for Illinois YouthBuild, a nonprofit organization with 16
programs providing job training for disadvantaged youth.
taxes are nothing new, of course. The federal gasoline tax raises about
$25 billion per year, with most of that dedicated to the Highway Trust
Fund. Governments are especially fond of so-called "sin taxes" targeting
irresponsible or undesirable behavior. That's why we see cigarette tax
revenue going towards lung cancer research, soda taxes targeting
obesity, and even a new 10% tax on tanning bed revenue.
sneaker tax sounds simple enough -- especially compared to, say, the
rules for Alternative Minimum Tax net operating loss carry forwards.
(That's a real thing, by the way, and it's every bit as awful as it
sounds.) But as is usually the case with taxes, the devil's in the
details. Davis's tax would apply to any "shoe designed primarily for
sports or other forms of physical activity." So, does "walking" count?
What about hiking boots, ski boots, or snowshoes? Will there be
refundable credits for sneaker-buying families earning less than the
But the real problem is that Rep. Davis's sneaker tax might open the floodgates to imitators. Just consider what other targeted taxes might be next:
- A tax on Valentine's Day flowers to support marriage counseling services?
- A tax on snowplows to support research into global climate change?
- A tax on footballs to keep replacement refs off the field?
- A tax on "reality TV" shows to support public broadcasting?
Nobody really wants to see new taxes, of course. But we all know we have to pay something. What sort of new tax could you support, and where would you spend the revenue it raises? Let us know what you think. And remember, no matter what gets taxed, we're here to help you pay less!
Hoffman counsels Entrepreneurs, Professionals and Select Individuals in
taking control of their taxes, and businesses. Discover how I can help
you overcome your tax and business challenges. To start the conversation
or to become a client, call Kenneth Hoffman at (954) 591-8290 Monday -
Friday between 8:30 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. for a no cost consultation, or
drop me a note.
If you found this article helpful, I invite you to leave a commit and please share it on twitter, facebook or your favorite social media site and with your friends, family and colleagues. Thank you.
I truly value your business and I appreciate your referrals. Refer your family, friends, acquaintances, and business colleagues to KR Hoffman & Co., LLC. If your referral retains our services, we will send you a $25 gift card and your referral will receive a $25 discount on their first invoice.
Follow us on Twitter at @TaxReturnCoach, and let us know how we're doing.